Focusing on Actors in Context-Specific, Data-Informed Theories of Change to Increase Inclusion in Quality Basic Education Reforms

  • Jessica Ball University of Victoria
  • Mariam Smith Learning Loop Consultancy
Keywords: Theory of Change, Indigenous, Actor-focused, Complexity, Outcomes, Situated learning, Multilingual education, Systems, Participation, Social justice, Rights, Social change

Abstract

This article describes an actor-focused approach to creating a theory of change that is context-specific, grounded in an understanding of local historical, cultural, linguistic, and social realities, and inspired by a commitment to social justice in education reform. In 2019, the authors completed a research evaluation of the Government of Cambodia’s inaugural Multilingual Education National Action Plan designed to increase inclusion of Indigenous children in basic education. The project mandate included constructing a theory of change. Using the participatory approach of Outcome Harvesting, data were obtained about behavioral changes among actors implementing and affected by the plan. Qualitative data analyses identified 115 behaviors distributed across 15 categories of actors in the education system, and uncovered assumptions and experiences of change processes and relationships. The authors created a generic theory of change mandated by the commissioning body for the evaluation. It was unidirectional and institution-centered, focused on objectives, strategies, outputs, and outcomes. To provide a more nuanced, inclusive, context-specific and potentially useful representation of change processes, the authors drew upon the behavior change data to construct a second, actor-focused theory of change. Additionally, the authors constructed a third theory of change showing education strategies in the current context compared to internationally accepted best practice in multilingual education. This study illustrates a focus on manifest behaviors and relationships among actors in theories of change. Actor-focused frameworks that describe situationally specific, participatory action and reciprocal learning can promote inclusive, sustainable, systems-level change toward children’s right to meaningful quality basic education.

Author Biographies

Jessica Ball, University of Victoria

Jessica Ball is a professor at the University of Victoria. She has developed and taught courses about early childhood health and development and evaluation research methods at universities in Canada, the United States, and several countries in Asia. She developed, delivered, and evaluated programs for numerous international organizations and government ministries of education. Her research is often partnered with communities, and focuses on determinants of marginalization and promising practices for inclusion of migrant, minoritized, and Indigenous children and families.

Mariam Smith, Learning Loop Consultancy

Mariam Smith is an independent consultant (Learning Loop Inc.), supporting program teams’ and community members’ learning through program design, meaningful monitoring systems, and evaluation. She specializes in actor-centered methodologies including Outcome Mapping and Outcome Harvesting. Most of her work has been within the field of international development and education in Scandinavia and in Southeast Asia, where she lived for 15 years working with Indigenous rights and education. She speaks several dominant and Indigenous languages, and has conducted international evaluations of government and non-government initiatives to promote children’s learning in their home language.

Published
2020-03-30